What this page is
When you engage me for an Art Review, I take on confidentiality obligations. Those obligations are set out in clause B13 of the Terms of Service and in the Art Review Services Agreement. They are deliberately strong, and they are permanent so far as you are concerned: your identity — including your name and your address — the photographs and documents you send me before I deliver your report (or, if there is no report, before the engagement ends), and the fact that you engaged me at all stay confidential indefinitely.
This page is about the artworks, not about you.
I have already carried out extensive independent research on every work listed below, and my own independent analysis of the further categories described in the next section. That work was done prior to, and independently of, any client engagement. It is my own work and my own material. I therefore cannot and do not offer any confidentiality undertaking in respect of these works, and I remain free to discuss, write about, film, publish and otherwise use my findings about them, whenever and however I choose.
If you are considering commissioning an Art Review, read this list first. If the artwork you have in mind appears here, or falls within one of the categories below, I will tell you in writing and you choose what happens next. By default the engagement is declined and your Quotation Fee is refunded in full — you need do nothing for that to happen. Alternatively you may tell me in writing, separately and after I have told you, that you want me to go ahead anyway; in that case the engagement continues, no refund is due on this ground, and no confidentiality undertaking attaches to the artwork itself or to anything I find in it. Your identity, your address and your photographs stay confidential permanently in either case. What changes is the artwork. If you take the default option and the engagement is declined, there is no report and nothing to keep confidential. If instead you tell me to go ahead, then for that engagement no confidentiality attaches to the artwork itself or to anything I find in it, and the five-year confidentiality that clause B13(d) would otherwise give the contents of your report does not apply — although my promises not to buy, sell or otherwise deal in the artwork keep running, as they would for any other client.
If you go ahead, your report will contain only what I find that is new. Nothing I had already found in the artwork before you paid the Quotation Fee goes into it: that earlier work is not what you are paying for. Before you decide, I will tell you roughly how much examination I have already done on the artwork, and that a new review may well find nothing new. If your artwork is one of several versions covered by a single entry in the list, anything I had already found in any of those versions stays out of your report, so a report on your version may say little. See clause B9 of the Terms.
The excluded categories in full
The exclusion covers all of the following:
- (a) every artwork listed on this page in the table below;
- (b) the picture book Nicky's Secret: A Christmas Story and every image, illustration and element within it, along with the many artworks that its illustrations allude to, nearly all of which are individually listed on this page anyway;
- (c) every artwork discussed, shown or referred to in any video, article, or post published on The Hunch Trail YouTube channel, The Hunch Trail Instagram channel, The Hunch Trail Tiktok profile, The Hunch Trail Twitch channel, The Hunch Trail Pinterest page, The Hunch Trail Reddit page, The Hunch Trail X (Twitter) profile, The Hunch Trail LinkedIn page, or The Hunch Trail Facebook page;
- (d) every artwork discussed, shown or referred to in any article, post, newsletter, video, image, or other material published on any other public channel operated by The Hunch Trail; and
- (e) any artwork added to this page from time to time.
Whether your artwork is on this list is judged as at the day you pay the Quotation Fee. If it is not on the list and does not fall within a category then, it does not become excluded, as against your engagement, because of something I publish or add here afterwards — and the confidentiality you already have is not cut down by any later listing. See clause B9 of the Terms.
I add works to this page from time to time. A work does not need to appear in the table to fall within categories (b), (c), (d) or (e) — the categories operate independently of the list, and the list is not exhaustive of the works I have analysed.
What this page does not do
Listing a work here does not mean:
- that I claim to have made any discovery about it;
- that I make any claim about its attribution, authenticity, provenance, condition or value;
- that I have any interest in it, or any intention to transact in it; or
- that any opinion I hold about it is correct, complete or capable of verification.
Everything I publish about any artwork is a subjective opinion arrived at by a manual visual examination of photographs, by me personally, without automated analysis or AI, using a method of my own that has not been tested, peer-reviewed or published in the scientific literature. It is not a valuation, not an authentication, not an attribution, and not advice. See clause A8 of the Terms of Service.
Nothing on this page limits any obligation I have under a law that cannot be excluded by agreement, including any obligation of confidence imposed by a court or by statute.
The list
Listed by artist, in alphabetical order of the name under which that artist is conventionally filed — so Leonardo da Vinci appears under L, Jan van Eyck under E, and El Greco under G. Works whose artist is not known are grouped together at the end. Where a work exists in more than one version and the entry says so, every version is covered — and anything I had already found in any of those versions counts as already found for all of them.
| Artwork | Artist |
|---|---|
| A Ceiling Fresco in the Apostolic Palace | Giovanni Alberti |
| Agony in the Garden | Giovanni Bellini |
| Madonna del Prato | Giovanni Bellini |
| Behemoth and Leviathan (Book of Job illustrations) | William Blake |
| Satan Smiting Job with Sore Boils | William Blake |
| Agony in the Garden | Carl Bloch |
| Christ Healing the Sick at Bethesda | Carl Bloch |
| Christ in Gethsemane | Carl Bloch |
| The Garden of Earthly Delights | Hieronymus Bosch |
| Visions of the Hereafter | Hieronymus Bosch |
| Primavera | Sandro Botticelli |
| The Temptations of Christ (Sistine Chapel) | Sandro Botticelli |
| Dante and Virgil in Hell | William Bouguereau |
| El Hijo Pródigo (The Prodigal Son) | Giacinto Brandi |
| The Tower of Babel | Pieter Bruegel the Elder |
| The Triumph of Death | Pieter Bruegel the Elder |
| The Mérode Altarpiece | Robert Campin |
| The Calling of Saint Matthew | Caravaggio |
| Conversion on the Way to Damascus | Caravaggio |
| Deposition of Christ | Caravaggio |
| Salome with the Head of John the Baptist | Caravaggio |
| Supper at Emmaus | Caravaggio |
| Pietà | Agostino Carracci |
| St Jerome | Cesare da Sesto |
| Route de village, Auvers | Paul Cézanne |
| Ecce Homo | Antonio Ciseri |
| The Virgin and Child | Carlo Crivelli |
| Christ of Saint John of the Cross | Salvador Dalí |
| Portrait of Michelangelo | Daniele da Volterra |
| The Three Legends of Saint Nicholas | Gerard David |
| Portrait previously attributed to Paolo Uccello (Louvre) | Donatello (attributed) |
| The Raising of Lazarus | Duccio di Buoninsegna |
| Christ Among the Doctors | Albrecht Dürer |
| The Arnolfini Portrait | Jan van Eyck |
| The Ghent Altarpiece (The Adoration of the Mystic Lamb) | Jan van Eyck and Hubert van Eyck |
| Adoration of the Magi | Lavinia Fontana |
| Noli me Tangere | Lavinia Fontana |
| Mankind's Eternal Dilemma: The Choice Between Virtue and Vice | Frans Francken II |
| Virgin and Child with Saint Anne | Gortzius Geldorp |
| Adoration of the Magi | Artemisia Gentileschi |
| The Birth of St John the Baptist | Artemisia Gentileschi |
| David and Bathsheba | Artemisia Gentileschi |
| The Last Supper | Giampietrino |
| Adoration of the Magi | Luca Giordano |
| The Fall of the Rebel Angels | Luca Giordano |
| The Tempest | Giorgione |
| Adoration of the Magi | Giotto |
| Death and Ascension of St Francis | Giotto |
| Joachim's Vision of the Angel | Giotto |
| Lamentation (The Mourning of Christ) | Giotto |
| Café Terrace at Night | Vincent van Gogh |
| Christ Driving the Moneychangers from the Temple | El Greco |
| The Adultress before Christ | Heinrich Hofmann |
| The Arrest of Christ | Heinrich Hofmann |
| Christ and the Rich Young Ruler | Heinrich Hofmann |
| Christ in Gethsemane | Heinrich Hofmann |
| Christ in the Temple | Heinrich Hofmann |
| Christ's Image | Heinrich Hofmann |
| Mädchen eine Laute spielend (Girl Playing a Lute) | Heinrich Hofmann |
| The Ambassadors | Hans Holbein the Younger |
| The Light of the World (all versions) | William Holman Hunt |
| The Prophet Elijah in the Desert Awakened by an Angel | Giovanni Lanfranco |
| The Adoration of the Magi | Leonardo da Vinci |
| The Annunciation (Uffizi and Louvre versions) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Bacchus (originally Saint John the Baptist) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| The Benois Madonna | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Ginevra de' Benci | Leonardo da Vinci |
| The Last Supper | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Leda and the Swan (Melzi's copy, Uffizi — after Leonardo) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Madonna and Child with the Infant Saint John the Baptist (all versions, including Leonardo da Vinci's workshop versions, and versions painted after by other artists) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Madonna Litta | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Madonna of the Carnation (Carnation Madonna) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Madonna of the Yarnwinder (the Buccleuch, Lansdowne, Museo Soumaya and Christ Church Oxford versions) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Mona Lisa | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Portrait of a Musician | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Saint Jerome in the Wilderness | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Saint John the Baptist | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Salvator Mundi | Leonardo da Vinci |
| The Virgin and Child with Saint Anne | Leonardo da Vinci |
| The Virgin and Child with Saint Anne and Saint John the Baptist (Burlington House Cartoon) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Virgin of the Rocks (Louvre and London versions) | Leonardo da Vinci |
| Penitent Magdalene (attributed) | Leonardo da Vinci / Salai |
| The Son of Man (Le fils de l'homme) | René Magritte |
| Saint Sebastian (Kunsthistorisches Museum, Vienna) | Andrea Mantegna |
| The Triumph of the Immaculate | Paolo de Matteis |
| The Last Judgement (triptych) | Hans Memling |
| David (statue) | Michelangelo |
| The Last Judgement (Sistine Chapel altar wall) | Michelangelo |
| Manchester Madonna | Michelangelo |
| Moses (statue) | Michelangelo |
| Pietà (statue) | Michelangelo |
| The Sistine Chapel ceiling | Michelangelo |
| Christ in the House of His Parents | John Everett Millais |
| Merry Old Santa Claus | Thomas Nast |
| The Pool | Palma il Giovane |
| The Delivery of the Keys to Saint Peter | Pietro Perugino |
| Flagellation of Christ | Piero della Francesca |
| Christ Giving the Keys to St Peter | Giovanni Battista Pittoni |
| Paul and Silas Leaving the Prison in Philippi | Nicolas de Plattemontagne |
| The Deposition | Raphael |
| The Holy Family | Raphael |
| Madonna of the Pinks | Raphael |
| Saint Michael Vanquishing Satan | Raphael |
| The Sistine Madonna | Raphael |
| The Transfiguration | Raphael |
| The Ascension of Christ | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| Bathsheba at Her Bath | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| Belshazzar's Feast | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| Christ in the Storm on the Sea of Galilee | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| David and Jonathan | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| Moses Breaking the Tablets | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| The Raising of Lazarus | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| The Return of the Prodigal Son | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| St Peter in Prison | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| Susanna and the Elders | Rembrandt van Rijn |
| The Devil's Checkmate | Moritz Retzsch |
| Daniel in the Lion's Den | Briton Rivière |
| Daniel's Answer to the King | Briton Rivière |
| The Israelites Leaving Egypt | David Roberts |
| The Elevation of the Cross | Peter Paul Rubens |
| Samson and Delilah | Peter Paul Rubens |
| The Garden of Eden with the Fall of Man | Peter Paul Rubens & Jan Brueghel the Elder |
| The Holy Family Beneath the Portico | Friedrich Wilhelm Schadow |
| Joseph Interpreting Dreams in Prison | Friedrich Wilhelm Schadow |
| Agony in the Garden | Frans Schwartz |
| Portrait of an Elderly Woman | Frans Schwartz |
| Self-Portrait | Frans Schwartz |
| The Preaching of the Antichrist (Orvieto Cathedral) | Luca Signorelli |
| The Resurrection of the Flesh | Luca Signorelli |
| The Well of Moses | Claus Sluter |
| The Feast of Saint Nicholas (Sinterklaasavond) | Jan Steen |
| The Calling of St Matthew | Bernardo Strozzi |
| The Conversion of Zacchaeus | Bernardo Strozzi |
| Madonna and Child with Infant Saint John | Bernardo Strozzi |
| Rebecca and Eliezer at the Well | Bernardo Strozzi |
| The Prophet Isaiah / The Calling of Isaiah | Giovanni Battista Tiepolo |
| Miracle of the Slave | Tintoretto |
| Paradise (Doge's Palace, Venice) | Tintoretto |
| Assumption of the Virgin | Titian |
| Averoldi Polyptych | Titian |
| Christ and the Good Thief | Titian |
| The Crowning with Thorns | Titian |
| Ecce Homo | Titian |
| Fall of Man | Titian |
| Noli me Tangere | Titian |
| Pietà | Titian |
| The Tribute Money | Titian |
| The Parable of the Wicked Tenants | Maarten van Valckenborch |
| The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse | Viktor Vasnetsov |
| Supper at Emmaus | Diego Velázquez |
| Fishing for Souls | Adriaen Pietersz van de Venne |
| Allegory of Faith | Johannes Vermeer |
| Woman Holding a Balance | Johannes Vermeer |
| The Feast in the House of Levi | Paolo Veronese |
| The Baptism of Christ | Andrea del Verrocchio (with Leonardo da Vinci) |
| Salem | Sydney Curnow Vosper |
| Christ Carrying the Cross (1500; sometimes suggested as Leonardo da Vinci) | artist unknown |
| Daniel in the Lion's Den (photographed by Heinz Tschanz-Hofmann) | artist unknown |
| 'Gruss vom Krampus' ('Greetings from Krampus') greeting card, c.1900s | artist unknown |
| The Letter of Lentulus pamphlet sketch (London, 1680) | artist unknown |
| Martin Luther as Junker Jörg, from 'Doktor Luthers Leben, Thaten und Meinungen' | artist unknown |
If your artwork is on this list
If you have already paid the Quotation Fee and the artwork turns out to be listed here or to fall within one of the categories above, I will tell you in writing. Unless you tell me within ten Business Days that you want to proceed anyway, I decline the engagement and refund the Quotation Fee in full under clause B4(b) of the Terms. If you do tell me to proceed, your report will contain only what I find that is new, as explained above.
You are welcome to contact me before paying anything. Use the enquiry form on the home page or email email@hunchtrail.com. You do not need to identify the artwork to ask a general question, and I would rather answer it than take a fee I am going to refund. Neither the enquiry form nor email@hunchtrail.com is confidential, so please do not identify the artwork there. Confidentiality begins only once you have paid the Quotation Fee and I have emailed you from my own address — see clause B13 of the Terms.